Does This Book Suck Forum - Recent Topics

Author Submission Warning

Admin-tonymf — Thu, 14 May 2026 20:17:24 +0000

By submitting your book, cover, blurb, ad, or first page, you understand that reader feedback may be blunt, negative, profane, uncomfortable, or brutally honest.

You may receive thumbs down votes.

You may receive harsh comments.

You may disagree with the feedback.

You may ask clarifying questions, but you may not attack readers, demand praise, or require positive reviews.

This site does not sell reviews. It hosts reader opinions and feedback.

Submit only if you want honest reactions.

How Voting Works

Admin-tonymf — Thu, 14 May 2026 20:15:35 +0000

Every submission gets one simple vote:

👍 Doesn’t Suck
👎 Sucks

Then you can leave feedback in one of two styles:

Beautiful:
Say what worked, what hooked you, what made you want more.

Brutal:
Say what failed, what bored you, what confused you, what made you scroll past.

Profanity is allowed. Blunt feedback is allowed.

Personal attacks are not.

Say the book sucks. Don’t say the author does.

Test Roast: Does This Cover Suck?

Admin-tonymf — Thu, 14 May 2026 20:11:42 +0000

This is a test post for the Does This Cover Suck section.

Vote with:

👍 Doesn’t suck
👎 Sucks

Then leave feedback as:

Beautiful: what works
Brutal: what fails

Rule: Say the cover sucks. Don’t say the author does.

Caution: Thick Skin Required

Admin-tonymf — Thu, 14 May 2026 19:55:06 +0000

This site allows profanity, blunt criticism, and brutally honest reader reactions.

Feedback may be beautiful or brutal. That is the point.

Personal attacks, hate speech, threats, doxxing, harassment, slurs, spam, and false factual accusations are not allowed.

Say the book sucks. Don’t say the author does.

Be brutal about the work. Be decent to the person.

Reviews, votes, and comments are reader opinions. Authors may not demand praise, guaranteed reviews, or positive feedback.